Home > Local News > The view from Cambodia

The view from Cambodia


Michael Hayes

When I was publisher and editor-in-chief of The Phnom Penh Post I was
sued once by then-Second Prime Minister Hun Sen, accused of spreading
disinformation and trying to create political instability. Over the
years, several Cambodian government officials even accused me and my
newspaper of attempting to “destroy the nation”.

Photo by: Michael Hayes

Villagers displaced by the fighting line up to receive emergency food aid donated by HM King Norodom Sihamoni.

At the very
least I’ve never been called a spin doctor for the Cambodian government. But on the issue of the current border dispute between
Cambodia and Thailand surrounding Wat Preah Vihear, I’m as angry as all
Cambodians are at what we perceive as a Thai-initiated conflict of
grossly unjust proportions.
We are not alone. Since this
issue flared up two years ago, I have not met one Asian or Western
diplomat, one foreign aid worker or one expatriate businessman in Phnom
Penh who disagrees. Even a few Thai friends have sheepishly expressed
support for the Cambodian side on this spat.
The nagging question
that perplexes us all is why Thailand is trying to export its domestic
political problems and dump them on poor Cambodia? The sentiment here
is that if the red shirts and the yellow shirts want to fight it out,
do so somewhere in Thailand, but don’t use Cambodia as a scapegoat.
view from Cambodia is simple: the issue of sovereignty over the temple
was decided back in 1962 when the case was submitted to the
International Court of Justice in The Hague.  
If Thailand didn’t
want to abide by the court’s ruling then why did it agree to submit the
case in the first place? And why are they groaning now and firing
artillery shells at the temple almost 50 years later?
when Thailand says: Well, we controlled the temple in the 1800s and
before, the Khmers have a simpler reply: Yeah, but WE BUILT IT! We
started construction in the early 9th century, modified and improved it
for 250 years and then continued to pray there and celebrate our Gods
for another three centuries until you guys stole it after you sacked
and looted our capital at Angkor Wat three times between 1352 and 1431.
Thank you very much. End of story.
Cambodia has no interest
whatsoever in another protracted violent conflict with anybody. The
Kingdom is still trying to recover from 30 years of civil war, Pol Pot
madness and the ensuing guerilla conflict in the ’80s and ’90s that in
total cost the lives of more than 2.5 million Cambodians and left the
country in ruins. Every dollar spent on the military conflict there is
a dollar lost for building desperately needed roads, schools and
The Thai accusation that Cambodia has had some secret plot to steal Thai land along the border is also seen as ludicrous.
knows that since 1970 Cambodia has been too consumed with domestic
strife to take even one metre of land from any of its neighbours. In
fact, foreign aid officials who worked on the Thai border in the ’80s
will readily admit that border creep worked in reverse. It was Thai
farmers living in peace – and I’m not accusing the Thai government of
some orchestrated campaign here – who took the opportunity to plant a
few extra hectares in disputed border areas while internally Cambodia
was in complete disarray.
If there is one thing that is clear, it
is that the entire border needs to be systematically surveyed and
demarcated, step by step, once and for all.
As for the disputed
4.5 square kilometres just north of the temple, why not consider this: 
Turn the area into the Cambodian-Thai International Friendship Park and
set it up as a jointly managed enterprise by both countries’ Ministries
of Tourism. Invite in hawkers, entrepreneurs, whatever, from both sides
of the border to set up businesses to cater to the millions of tourists
who will want to visit the site in the coming decades and beyond. Tax
revenues could be shared by both nations equally. Everybody wins.
It could also be a model for other border disputes around the globe.
the Thais want a protracted, bloody fight on their hands over the
temple, they’ve got one. In the 20 years I’ve been in Cambodia the
Preah Vihear issue is without question the only one I’ve seen that has
united the entire nation. Cambodian TV stations have been running
fundraisers off and on with donations large and small pouring in from
all quarters for two years. Even the normally truculent Sam Rainsy
Party and others in the opposition are fully on board.
It’s clear
from a visit to the temple last week that the Cambodian military has
dug in for the long haul. New heavy tanks, armoured personnel carriers
and ammunition “donated by friendly countries” are evident all over the
base of the escarpment. Battle-scarred veterans, no doubt from all of
Cambodia’s four previously warring factions and including ex-Khmer
Rouge who controlled the temple from 1975 to 1998, are now all
operating under one flag.
And yes, of course there are Cambodian
soldiers with weapons bunkered around the temple. If they weren’t there
the Thai military could literally walk in and take control of it in
five minutes. What government in Phnom Penh could allow that?
this dispute goes real hot, relations between Cambodia and Thailand
will be ruined for years, hundreds on both sides will die needlessly
and the economic costs to the two countries will be astronomical.
heads need to prevail, but rest assured the Cambodians will never, no
matter what the price, give up control of Wat Preah Vihear.
Why should they? It’s theirs.

Michael Hayes co-founded The Phnom Penh Post in 1992 and was Publisher and Editor-in-Chief from 1992 to 2008.
Phnom Penh Post
Categories: Local News
  1. Anonymous
    February 18, 2011 at 1:24 pm

    Good view except for the one talking about shared Cambo-Thai park. How can u possibly say shared revenues between the two countries when it's clearly as day that it's Cambodia territory??

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: